Delayed data

Education, not investment advice. Trading can lose you money. How we check every fact

News analysis ·

Polymarket's CFTC probe: are prediction markets safe?

The CFTC is reportedly probing whether Polymarket kept US users off its offshore site. What that means for traders who use event-contract platforms.

A commuter in a dark coat taps a phone on a reader at a New York subway fare gate, with steel gates and green lights to the right.
Photo: Metropolitan Transportation Authority from United States of America / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0 (cropped)

The US derivatives regulator is reportedly investigating whether Polymarket honoured a 2022 promise to keep American customers off its offshore prediction market. Unchained, citing a Reuters report, said the review covers how the company checked where users were. This article looks at what that means for a trader using a platform that was never meant to serve them.

What the CFTC is reportedly looking at

According to Unchained, a Reuters story on Tuesday, based on two unnamed sources, said the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) is examining Polymarket's compliance with a settlement it reached in January 2022. In that deal, Polymarket resolved CFTC charges over listing binary options tied to events while not registered as an exchange. It paid a $1.4 million civil penalty, agreed to close markets that did not meet the Commodity Exchange Act, and, according to Reuters, committed to stop serving US users.

The review is said to cover how Polymarket decided which country a customer was in, the ads it ran for an American audience, and the sign-up process and safeguards on the US platform it launched late last year. One source told Reuters the scrutiny centres on the company's earlier checks. Reuters said these settlement questions sit inside a broader CFTC investigation opened earlier this year, which several outlets first reported in June.

The CFTC, the Justice Department and Polymarket did not comment to Reuters, which cautioned that an investigation does not necessarily mean wrongdoing.

Why this is not the first look

Regulators have been here before. Before the 2024 election, the CFTC checked Polymarket's compliance with the 2022 deal while the Justice Department ran its own inquiry, and the FBI searched CEO Shayne Coplan's New York home in November 2024. Both agencies dropped those reviews in July 2025 with no charges filed. Reuters said the new details cast doubt on the reasons the earlier probes were closed.

After that, Polymarket acquired a CFTC-licensed derivatives exchange and later used it to start its US business. The company says it has overhauled its controls, bans VPNs and similar tools for dodging location limits, and watches for misconduct. In August, Polymarket investigations head Shana Bautista told Reuters that US users evading the restrictions was not a widespread problem.

Are prediction markets safe? The mechanics

A prediction market lists event contracts: simple yes-or-no trades on whether something will happen. Each contract pays out if the event occurs and is worth nothing if it does not, so a trader can lose the whole stake. Whether that is a safe place for your money depends less on the contract itself and more on who runs the venue and which rules it follows.

A regulated US exchange answers to a US regulator and must follow rules on onboarding and market conduct. An offshore venue that has promised to exclude Americans owes a US user very little, because that user was never supposed to be there. Someone who reaches such a site by hiding their location, for example with a VPN (a tool that makes a connection appear to come from another country), steps outside the protections built for its intended customers.

The case of Gannon Ken Van Dyke shows how this can go wrong. In April, the CFTC and the Justice Department charged the US soldier, alleging he used inside information on Polymarket's offshore site to earn $400,000, and that a VPN was how he got onto it. Van Dyke denies the charges with a not guilty plea, and Polymarket says it referred the case to authorities. For ordinary traders, the lesson is that insider trading is a live risk in event markets: someone may know the outcome before you do.

Where the risk is

None of the reporting says customers have lost money in this probe. But the situation shows several concrete ways a trader can be exposed when access and regulation do not line up.

  • Account access: a platform under pressure over who it lets in may tighten checks, and an account opened from a restricted location can be frozen or closed, with funds tied up while it is reviewed.
  • Weak recourse: if you use a venue that was not meant to serve you, a home regulator may have little ability to help you in a dispute.
  • Informed counterparties: a yes-or-no contract is a bet against other traders, and some of them may hold information you do not, as the Van Dyke allegations illustrate.
  • Headline shocks: legal action against a platform can affect how freely it can operate, and markets on a venue can be closed if they do not meet the rules, as the 2022 settlement required.

What to watch

The probe adds to a busy stretch for the company. Unchained noted that it follows the reported exit of chief marketing officer Matthew Modabber days earlier, and comes under two weeks after Polymarket sued Ohio in federal court, pointing to new CFTC rules.

Points to follow: whether the CFTC or Polymarket comments publicly, whether the review leads to formal action or closes like the earlier ones, and whether the US platform's onboarding rules change. If you trade event contracts, check which entity you are signing up with, which regulator oversees it, and whether you may use it from where you live.

Sources

Drafted with an AI model using only the sources listed, and released automatically after software checks on figures and originality. Nobody edited it by hand. For learning only; it does not tell you what to buy or sell.

← All posts